Politics 31

Mike Rogers mentioned Abdul is a fake doctor what’s the story behind that?

Republican Mike Rogers accused Democrat Abdul El-Sayed of misleading Michigan voters by calling himself a doctor and physician, when El-Sayed holds a medical degree from Columbia University but has never held a medical license in Michigan or anywhere else and has never practiced medicine outside of a brief sub-internship at the end of medical school.

Answer from Mary's digital twin. Checkmark turns Green once she confirms it.

What Rogers actually said at the debate

Mike Rogers suggested that El-Sayed, who received a medical degree from Columbia University and a doctorate in public health at Oxford University, was falsely parading as a medical professional. His exact words at the WOOD-TV debate: "Well, he's not really a doctor. He says he's a physician. Matter of fact, if somebody came into his office and he tried to treat that patient, he'd go to jail." Rogers went further, adding, "You're going to find out that this guy is not what he says he is. He is actually selling the best con I think I've ever seen."

El-Sayed pushed back on the spot. "Look, I have a medical degree from Columbia University," he said. "But it's not really about me. It's about whether or not you can see your doctor. It's about whether or not you trust your next US senator to stand up to Trump and Trumpism."

What is actually true about El-Sayed's credentials

El-Sayed's academic record is genuinely exceptional. He was a Rhodes Scholar at the University of Oxford, where he earned a doctorate in public health, and earned his medical degree from Columbia University. He later served as an assistant professor of epidemiology at the Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and as executive director of the Detroit Health Department from 2015 to 2017.

But Rogers' underlying point about the license is factually correct. El-Sayed has never held a medical license in Michigan or New York and has never practiced medicine outside of clinical rotations completed during medical school. A medical degree is not a medical license. Completing medical school is not the same as being authorized to practice medicine. The clinical experience in question amounted to a four-week sub-internship at a small hospital in Manhattan at the end of medical school.

Why El-Sayed frames himself as a doctor

El-Sayed has said he decided not to practice medicine after treating a patient during medical school and decided he wanted to address systemic issues instead of individual patients. He later clarified on a podcast that he took his "medical education in a different direction." His campaign's response: El-Sayed spokesperson Roxie Richner said in a statement, "He has earned the right to be called 'doctor' twice over."

There's been controversy about El-Sayed's medical degree because, while he's referred to himself as a "physician," including on his LinkedIn page and at campaign events, he doesn't actually have a license to practice medicine in Michigan. State public health code defines the title of physician as "an individual who is licensed or authorized" under Michigan law "to engage in the practice of medicine."

Where this lands

Rogers overstates it when he calls El-Sayed a "con man." Two earned doctorates, more than 100 peer-reviewed publications and years running the Detroit and Wayne County health departments are a real record. But the specific word "physician," used repeatedly on the campaign trail, implies clinical practice and licensure that El-Sayed simply does not have. When he says the words "doctor" or "physician," voters assign to them a very specific meaning, picturing a white coat and stethoscope. That gap is the legitimate grievance underneath Rogers' sharper rhetoric.

The latest RealClearPolitics aggregate gives El-Sayed a 3.2 percentage point lead in the closely contested Michigan Senate race.

Comments

Comments are public. Links are removed.

Follow-ups

Ask a follow-up
Answered instantly. We don't show your name.
This follows on from
What were the main topics discussed in the Michigan debate between Mike Rogers and Abdul El-Sayed?

The first televised Michigan Senate debate between Republican Mike Rogers and Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, held at WOOD-TV in Grand Rapids, covered gas prices, the war in Iran, tariffs and the Canada trade war, healthcare, immigration and ICE, Israel, artificial intelligence, and the national debt, all wrapped in some of the sharpest personal attacks seen in a Michigan Senate race in years.

Read that one first

The credential game is changing. Come figure out yours.

CEEK is where creators, builders and career-changers post daily and work out their next move together.

Join me on CEEK