Motion seems to take great players and bring the worst out of them from Dele Alli, Mario Balotelli, Pogba,Vinicius Jnr who are the top 10 players that Morino has taken from the heights of greatness and makes to ruin their careers
The only name to remove from the original list is Vinicius Jr. — his brilliance was built in spite of people doubting him at Real Madrid, but that story has nothing to do with Mourinho.
Quick note before we get into the list: the question says "Morino" but means José Mourinho, and also names Vinicius Jr. as one of the victims. That one needs a correction upfront: Vinicius Jr. has never played under Mourinho. He came through Real Madrid's academy and developed under managers like Zinedine Zidane and Carlo Ancelotti. He is one of the best players in the world right now, so he does not belong on this list at all. The rest, though? Very much on point.
Here are the 10 players Mourinho genuinely took from their peak and left worse for the experience.
1. Dele Alli
Successive PFA Young Player of the Year awards served to highlight a player with the world at his feet. The departure of Mauricio Pochettino from Spurs in November 2019 was ultimately the beginning of the end for Dele, and Mourinho succeeded him, warning the midfielder that an unprofessional attitude could negatively impact his career. The playmaker was left out of the squad altogether on several occasions and Mourinho told him he was "lazy" in the Amazon All or Nothing documentary. He never recovered, drifting through Everton and loan spells before effectively disappearing from top-level football.
2. Paul Pogba
Mourinho publicly called Paul Pogba a "virus" at Manchester United. His no-nonsense style and huge expectations were seen as an attempt to reign in Pogba's eccentricities, with the player often frozen out and cast out to dry in front of the media and fans when results went against them. A World Cup winner reduced to a subplot in a manager's ego war.
3. Mohamed Salah
Mohamed Salah caught the eye of Mourinho after beating Chelsea almost single-handedly while playing for Basel. He was not given the chance to develop into the world-class talent he eventually became at Chelsea, and was sold. He went on to become arguably the best player in Premier League history at Liverpool under Jürgen Klopp.
4. Kevin De Bruyne
Same story, same club. Kevin De Bruyne was not given the chance to develop into the world-class talent he eventually became under Mourinho at Chelsea. He left for Wolfsburg, rebuilt, and became one of the finest midfielders of his generation at Manchester City.
5. Juan Mata
Juan Mata may be one of the most glaring examples. The Spaniard won Chelsea's Player of the Year in 2012 and 2013, playing a pivotal role for the Blues. Mourinho condemned Mata to the bench for a long time, an action Chelsea fans considered "unfair." At his exit from Stamford Bridge, Mourinho apologized that he did not make Mata "a better player."
6. Kaká
The decorated Brazilian midfielder was considered a success at Real Madrid before things changed drastically when Mourinho took over in 2010. The manager actively contributed to the player's decline by forcing him into a role that did not suit his natural abilities. Kaká never reached those heights again.
7. Luke Shaw
Mourinho's harsh post-match comments about Luke Shaw's fitness and "football brain" saw him ostracized from the team at Manchester United. Shaw later flourished under Ole Gunnar Solskjær, which only underlined how much of the problem was the manager, not the player.
8. John Obi Mikel
The Nigerian midfielder joined Chelsea in 2006, months after being adjudged the second most valuable player at the Under-20 World Cup. He felt "deprived" when he did not have the opportunity to express himself at Chelsea under Mourinho. A box-to-box talent was turned into a sitting cone for years.
9. Daniel Sturridge
Daniel Sturridge felt "deprived" when he did not have the opportunity to express himself at Chelsea under Mourinho. He left, joined Liverpool, and briefly became one of the most lethal strikers in Europe before injuries caught up with him.
10. Nuri Sahin
Nuri Sahin was a strange signing by Mourinho during his time at Real Madrid. He had all the talent to succeed, but Mourinho never bothered to give him the time to adapt. He played just a handful of minutes in one of the best squads in the world and was quietly shipped out.
The Pattern
The thread running through every name on this list is the same: Mourinho's ego and his need for control over narrative became more important than the player's development. Perhaps more impressive than his ability to pick up silverware is his uncanny way of doing so while seemingly falling out with every player he manages. He wins trophies, then burns the house down on his way out. The players who thrived under him were either physically dominant types who fit his defensive structure, or veterans secure enough in themselves not to need his approval. Anyone creative, independent-minded or still developing got crushed.
Follow-ups
Why do they keep hiring Mourinho?
Real Madrid hired José Mourinho because, after two straight trophy-less seasons and a dressing room in open revolt, club president Florentino Pérez decided the problem was not tactical, it was authority, and Mourinho is the one manager on earth whose personality alone ends that conversation.
Real Madrid hired José Mourinho because, after two straight trophy-less seasons and a dressing room in open revolt, club president Florentino Pérez decided the problem was not tactical, it was authority, and Mourinho is the one manager on earth whose personality alone ends that conversation.
The situation that made Mourinho the answer
Real Madrid hired Mourinho after two consecutive trophy-less seasons, back-to-back Champions League group-stage exits, and a fractured dressing room that three previous managers failed to fix. The dressing room had fractured under Álvaro Arbeloa due to public clashes, ego conflicts, and an absence of discipline. When a club of that size goes two years without silverware and its own players are openly disrespecting the manager on the touchline, it needs someone the players are more afraid of than they are of looking bad.
Why Mourinho specifically
According to MARCA, Real Madrid's decision to bring back Mourinho was driven by more than tactics. It was about authority. The club wanted Mourinho to put an end to the disrespect that Xabi Alonso and Arbeloa had suffered, with the message behind the appointment described as: "Let's see who raises their arms now."
Mourinho was not hired to be liked by everyone. He was hired to take control. His intimate knowledge of the club and his larger-than-life aura made him, in Pérez's mind, the greatest candidate to work his magic in Madrid.
That personal relationship matters too. Mourinho fell out with a lot of people while in charge of Real Madrid the first time, but president Florentino Pérez was not one of them. When a club president trusts a manager that much, the criticism from outside barely registers.
The uncomfortable truth about why this keeps happening
Mourinho gets hired for the same reason he eventually gets fired: he is extreme. When a club is in chaos, extreme authority feels like the cure. When things stabilize, that same extremity becomes the new problem. His track record of wearing out dressing rooms eventually is well documented, and it is why his spells rarely last more than 3 years anywhere. But clubs in crisis do not think about year 3. They think about right now.
Despite past tensions, Real Madrid's leadership appeared convinced that Mourinho's personality is exactly what the current squad needs, with enormous curiosity surrounding how he will manage superstars like Kylian Mbappé and Vinícius Júnior amid reports of internal tensions.
The pattern holds across his whole career: a club hits a wall, patience runs out, someone says "we need someone who can impose himself," and Mourinho's name lands on the table. He will almost certainly do what he always does, restore order, win something, then push one relationship too far. And a few years after he leaves, some other club in crisis will call him again.
Build your own story, not someone else's blueprint.
CEEK is where creators and builders share what's actually working, in daily posts and a community of people building something real.
Join me on CEEK
Comments
Comments are public. Links are removed.