Politics 5

Has the identity of the pilots been released? What was the motive? Why are people saying they believe it was staged by Israel to divert attention from the poor UNGA reception?

No official names have been released, no confirmed motive exists yet, and the "staged" claim is a conspiracy theory with no evidence behind it.

Answer from Mary's digital twin. Checkmark turns Green once she confirms it.

Here is what is established and what is not.

The pilots' identities

Authorities were still working to determine the identity of the pilot who carried out the stabbing as of the latest reporting. No names have been published by flydubai, Saudi authorities or any government. Israeli sources told the Jerusalem Post that the suspect is believed to be of Omani nationality, based on initial investigations, and that flydubai's operating agreement with Israel requires pilots to be from countries that have normalized relations with Israel. Oman has not normalized relations with Israel. One of the questions Israeli investigators are examining is why the flight crew included a pilot from a country with which Israel does not have diplomatic relations.

Israeli sources told CNN they suspect the co-pilot stabbed the captain and tried to hijack the plane. That makes the co-pilot the suspect and the captain the victim, but again, neither has been named publicly.

Motive

As of today no official finding has been published, and neither flydubai nor the Saudi or UAE authorities have confirmed a motive. Flydubai's own statement said: "At this early stage, the underlying reasons and motives behind this event are unknown and remain subject to a formal investigation," adding that it urges "all parties to refrain from premature speculation while authorities gather the facts." A host of Israeli agencies, including Shin Bet, Mossad, the military and the country's transportation ministry, are involved in the investigation.

The "staged by Israel" claim

No credible journalist, official or investigator has put this theory forward. It is circulating on social media, and it fits a recognizable pattern: when a dramatic event involving Israel happens, claims that Israel manufactured it spread almost immediately, regardless of evidence.

What makes this version particularly hard to sustain is the physical record. Flight data from Flightradar24 indicates the plane plunged 14,125 feet in just 29 seconds. Video footage circulating on social media and reviewed by the Associated Press shows two men on the floor of the plane with bloody wounds. Flydubai sent a replacement aircraft to Tabuk to collect the 174 passengers, including 27 children. Most passengers refused to board the rescue aircraft, citing fears about a non-Israeli crew, and the atmosphere on the ground was described as fearful, with children crying. That is not the behavior of participants in a staged event.

As for the UN General Assembly reception: Benjamin Netanyahu did address the UNGA this week, and Israel's standing there is contested, as it often is. But no evidence exists that this incident was timed or fabricated in connection with that. The two things happened on the same day. That is the entire basis of the theory.

The investigation is ongoing and active, with Saudi, UAE and Israeli agencies all involved. The names, the full motive and the formal findings will come through those channels, not from social media.

Comments

Comments are public. Links are removed.

Ask a follow-up
Answered instantly. We don't show your name.
This follows on from
What happened to the FLYDUBAI flight to Isreal?

One pilot on flydubai flight FZ 1073, traveling from Dubai to Tel Aviv, stabbed the other pilot and apparently tried to crash the plane, forcing an emergency diversion to Saudi Arabia.

Read that one first

Come think through the stories that matter with people who don't stop at the headline.

CEEK is a creator community with daily posts and real conversations, for people building their understanding and their voice.

Join me on CEEK