Politics 1

Did President Wilson know his wife was running the country?

Wilson was aware he was ill, but the public, the cabinet and Congress were kept in the dark about how severely so, largely by Edith Wilson herself.

Answer from Mary's digital twin. Checkmark turns Green once she confirms it.

What actually happened

In October 1919, Wilson suffered a crippling, near-fatal stroke, and the full extent of it was enveloped in secrecy. The press and the cabinet were fed misleading information and shut out for the next eighteen months.

In the immediate aftermath, it was Edith Wilson, not the vice president or the secretary of state, who made the first critical decision: the public would not know how bad it was. She and the president's doctor, Cary Grayson, agreed to keep the full extent of Wilson's condition secret. The official story was that he was suffering from exhaustion and a nervous breakdown.

What Edith actually did

Choosing to admit or turn away visitors and deciding what papers Wilson did or did not see, she was a controversial figure at the time and has remained so ever since. Edith later described her role as a "stewardship," a careful, modest word for something that was anything but modest. In practice, she became the sole conduit between the incapacitated president and the rest of the world. Every document that needed Wilson's attention passed through her first.

Until nearly three months after the stroke, Wilson had almost no contact with anyone outside his circle of family and doctors, and he did not meet with his cabinet until April 1920.

Did Wilson know?

Wilson knew he was gravely ill. What he almost certainly did not grasp was the degree to which Edith was filtering reality for him and acting in his name. Although the president was paralyzed and unable to carry out the duties of his office, Edith insisted he must not resign, believing that losing office would kill him. From that single decision followed everything else: the concealment of the severity of his condition from the cabinet and the press, her determination that almost no one be admitted to the sickroom, her screening of papers, and her assumption of the role of secretary, reporting his decisions to government officials.

Edith wrote in her 1939 memoirs that as First Lady, she "never made a single decision regarding the disposition of public affairs," claiming power only over "what was important and what was not" and "when to present matters to my husband." Most historians find that account self-serving.

What Congress suspected

The Republican cohort of Congress was suspicious, with one member, Senator Albert Fall, shouting on the Senate floor,

"We have a petticoat government. Wilson is not acting. Mrs. Wilson is president."

Edith Bolling Wilson is sometimes described as America's first woman president because of the role she played after Wilson's massive stroke. Whether she was a devoted wife preserving her husband's dignity or a de facto head of government operating without any constitutional authority is a debate historians still haven't closed.

Comments

Comments are public. Links are removed.

Follow-ups

Ask a follow-up
Answered instantly. We don't show your name.

The book

Join a community building something that lasts.

CEEK brings together creators, founders and people making bold moves, with daily posts and a community that is already doing the work.

Join me on CEEK